PS3 vs Xbox 360 vs Wii Year 1 Comparison

[BCA]

I'm taking IGN's games that scored from 8.0-10 in Year 1 for the Xbox 360, PS3, and Wii!


Xbox 360:

(by the end of 2006)

9 Range

Gears of War 9.4
Rainbow 6 Vegas 9.3
Oblivion 9.3
G.R.A.W. 9.2
F.E.A.R. 9.1
Splinter Cell Double Agent 9.0
Prey 9.0
Dead or Alive 4 9.0
Call of Duty 2 9.0


8 Range

NHL 2K7 8.9
Burnout Revenge 8.9
Call of Duty 3 8.8
PGR 3 8.8
NHL 07 8.7
Condemned 8.7
Viva Pinata 8.5
Tiger Woods 07 8.5
Madden 07 8.5
Saints Row 8.5
FNR 3 8.5
Lego Star Wars2 8.4
Perfect Dark Zero 8.4
2006 Fifa World Cup 8.4
Moto GP 06 8.4
Kameo 8.4
NBA 2K7 8.3
Dead Rising 8.3
Far Cry IP 8.3
Tony Hawk's AM 8.3
NFS Carbon 8.2
College Hoops 2K7 8.2
Marvel 8.2
LOTR 8.2
Tomb Raider Legend 8.2
Quake 4 8.1
Smackdown 07 8.0
Test Drive U 8.0
Hitman 8.0
King Kong 8.0
NFS Most Wanted 8.0
Madden 06 8.0

--------------------------------------------------------------------------



Playstation 3

(By the end of 2007)

9 Range

Rock Band 9.4
Call of Duty 4 9.4
Ratchet and Clank ToD 9.4
Ninja Gaiden Sigma 9.3
Oblivion 9.2
Uncharted 9.1
Resistance 9.1
Folklore 9.0
Unreal Tournament 3 9.0


8 Range

Guitar Hero III 8.9
Motorstorm 8.9
Skate 8.8
Warhawk 8.8
Virtua Fighter 5 8.8
NBA Street Homecourt 8.8
Rainbow 6 Vegas 8.7
NHL 08 8.6
NHL 2K7 8.6
Tiger Woods 08 8.5
NBA 2K7 8.5
Orange Box 8.4
DiRT 8.4
G.R.A.W. 2 8.3
College Hoops 2K7 8.3
FNR3 8.3
Madden 07 8.3
Tiger Woods 07 8.3
Ridge Racer 7 8.2
Stranglehold 8.1
F.E.A.R. 8.1
College Hoops 2K8 8.0
Time Crisis 4 8.0
LEGO Complete Saga 8.0
Eye of Judgement 8.0
SEGA Rally 8.0
NHL 2K8 8.0
The Bigs 8.0


-----------------------------------------------------------------------


Wii:


(by the end of 2007)

9 Range

Super Mario Galaxy 9.7
Metroid Prime 3 Corruption 9.5
Zelda: Twilight Princess 9.5
Zack and Wiki 9.0
Resident Evil4 9.0


8 Range

Super Paper Mario 8.9
Guitar Hero III 8.6
Trauma Center: New Blood 8.5
Madden 08 8.5
Scarface 8.5
Madden 07 8.5
Medal of Honor Heroes 2 8.4
Naruto Clash of Ninja R 8.4
MLB Power Pros 8.4
SSX Blur 8.4
Super Monkey Ball Banana Blitz 8.4
Mario Strikers Charged 8.3
Elebits 8.3
DBZ BT 2 8.3
Rayman Raving Rabbins 8.3
Geometry Wars Galaxies 8.0
LEGO Complete Saga 8.0
Fire Emblem: RD 8.0
Battalion Wars 2 8.0
Godfather 8.0
Excite Truck 8.0
Trauma Center: Second Opinion 8.0

[TheSwex]

My predictions for the console war are as follows:

Xbox 360 will end up in first place and be the Grand Champion.

Wii will end up in second place.

PS3 will remain in 3rd.

[Chibi Kitsune]

*subscribes*

[ca$hman]

Not another list wars thread.

[Chibi Kitsune]

^
subscribed

[2pro4show]

No offense really, but I'm getting tired of these threads. They all start out similarly, but they all gravitate towards the same old argument, and get finished off at the hands of the Lock Fairy.

[Fyrus]

Originally Posted by Walshie

I'm taking IGN's games that scored from 8.0-10 in Year 1 for the Xbox 360, PS3, and Wii!


Xbox 360:

(by the end of 2006)

9 Range

Gears of War 9.4
Rainbow 6 Vegas 9.3
Oblivion 9.3
G.R.A.W. 9.2
F.E.A.R. 9.1
Splinter Cell Double Agent 9.0
Prey 9.0
Dead or Alive 4 9.0
Call of Duty 2 9.0


8 Range

NHL 2K7 8.9
Burnout Revenge 8.9
Call of Duty 3 8.8
PGR 3 8.8
NHL 07 8.7
Condemned 8.7
Viva Pinata 8.5
Tiger Woods 07 8.5
Madden 07 8.5
Saints Row 8.5
FNR 3 8.5
Lego Star Wars2 8.4
Perfect Dark Zero 8.4
2006 Fifa World Cup 8.4
Moto GP 06 8.4
Kameo 8.4
NBA 2K7 8.3
Dead Rising 8.3
Far Cry IP 8.3
Tony Hawk's AM 8.3
NFS Carbon 8.2
College Hoops 2K7 8.2
Marvel 8.2
LOTR 8.2
Tomb Raider Legend 8.2
Quake 4 8.1
Smackdown 07 8.0
Test Drive U 8.0
Hitman 8.0
King Kong 8.0
NFS Most Wanted 8.0
Madden 06 8.0

--------------------------------------------------------------------------



Playstation 3

(By the end of 2007)

9 Range

Rock Band 9.4
Call of Duty 4 9.4
Ratchet and Clank ToD 9.4
Ninja Gaiden Sigma 9.3
Oblivion 9.2
Uncharted 9.1
Resistance 9.1
Folklore 9.0


8 Range

Guitar Hero III 8.9
Motorstorm 8.9
Skate 8.8
Warhawk 8.8
Virtua Fighter 5 8.8
NBA Street Homecourt 8.8
Rainbow 6 Vegas 8.7
NHL 08 8.6
NHL 2K7 8.6
Tiger Woods 08 8.5
NBA 2K7 8.5
Orange Box 8.4
DiRT 8.4
G.R.A.W. 2 8.3
College Hoops 2K7 8.3
FNR3 8.3
Madden 07 8.3
Tiger Woods 07 8.3
Ridge Racer 7 8.2
Stranglehold 8.1
F.E.A.R. 8.1
College Hoops 2K8 8.0
Time Crisis 4 8.0
LEGO Complete Saga 8.0
Eye of Judgement 8.0
SEGA Rally 8.0
NHL 2K8 8.0
The Bigs 8.0

* Waiting on Unreal Tournament 3


-----------------------------------------------------------------------

(Will do Wii list later)

I think we should remove the multi plats.

[Fornak]

I'm not sure if taking scores from 1 site is really accurate, but IGN has given pretty fair scores.

[boffo]

Originally Posted by Fyrus

I think we should remove the multi plats.

Then it would pretty much be the exact same thing as the thread that Darth Daver started, just with a chunk of the 360 games removed.

[Fyrus]

Originally Posted by boffo

Then it would pretty much be the exact same thing as the thread that Darth Daver started, just with a chunk of the 360 games removed.

Yeah, we've already established that.