There is a reason I gave Twilight Princess an 8.8

LOL Gamecube version of TP got higher than Wii version.
Not only does that prove his lack of qualification to even review games, it also proves he is morbidly obese and can't raise his arm in order to swing the sword in TP.

Originally Posted by Platinum

LOL Gamecube version of TP got higher than Wii version.
Not only does that prove his lack of qualification to even review games, it also proves he is morbidly obese and can't raise his arm in order to swing the sword in TP.

whered you get your signature?

Originally Posted by Platinum

LOL Gamecube version of TP got higher than Wii version.
Not only does that prove his lack of qualification to even review games, it also proves he is morbidly obese and can't raise his arm in order to swing the sword in TP.

IN his review he said the wii version was better though... meh, all other editors are still good though. (greg kasavin did give red steel a 5.5 soo maybe he is a fat review supporter too? hmm we'll see)

How on earth do you justify saying a game is better than another but giving it a lower score?

Tp for gc got an 8.9 but the wii version got an 8.8

Whats up with that?

I think the reason might be that TP on the Gamecube is a very good looking game, whereas the Wii should be capable of much more. That's by design of course, but because TP isn't living up to the full potential of the Wii they probably gave it a lower score.

And yes, 8.8 is a ridiculously low score for TP.

Jeff's review was so carelessly written. Its the same as the wii review. All it is, is copy and pasting gamecube over wii. It is changed about the controlls.

You people don't understand. He gave TP for Wii and 8.8 because of the movement involved with the Wii-Mote. The GC version got higher because of less movement, and because he can snack 8.9 times faster without moving his arms.

Now i'm about 30 hours into TP, it's just drove home how wrong Jeff was. I knew he was off with the 8.8, but TP is one of the best games i've played, well, since OoT.

Nice... apologists!
I get people mad at me just by saying how I did not enjoy LTTP. Zelda fanboys... psst.